September 15 2011 - The government has made either moderate or no progress on 22 of its 29 low-carbon commitments, says a detailed analysis of government action to achieve its own low-carbon commitments. In May 2010, the government described climate change as ‘one of the gravest threats we face’ and committed to ‘urgent action both here and abroad.’1
Download the report now
The new study suggests there are low levels of support for the government’s low carbon agenda in the Treasury and the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills and concludes that major opportunities to generate green jobs and increase investor confidence in the low carbon sector are being missed.
Climate Check is published by think tank Green Alliance in conjunction with WWF, Christian Aid, Greenpeace and RSPB. It is the product of five months’ research and extensive discussions with over 40 officials and ministers across Whitehall.
The 48-page report examines progress across 11 departments and concludes:
• So far, the government has made some good, high-profile decisions on important policies such as the 4th Carbon Budget, but its overall record is weakened by delayed or poorly-designed policies on many other coalition commitments. ‘
• Seven commitments have been delivered successfully or achieving good progress – for instance, there has been a nearly 14 per cent reduction in emissions across central government.
• On a further six policies, the Coalition is failing – for instance, the Treasury has made no progress towards creating green financial products.
• On the remaining 16 policies there is only moderate progress, due to delay (10), poor policy design (9), or both. The Green Deal, for example, is at risk of failing because of a lack of urgency and support across government departments.
• There are clear indications that the Treasury and to a lesser extent BIS have curbed, or attempted to curb, the government’s ambition on the low carbon agenda.
• However, contrary to what observers might expect, there is little evidence of division along party lines. Both Conservative and Liberal Democrat champions of low carbon policies have been held back by others within their own party.
As well as assessing the government’s low-carbon record so far, Climate Check identifies three big opportunities which would help the government fulfil its stated goal to ‘decarbonise the economy and support the creation of new green jobs and technologies’.
These involve increasing cross-government accountability for the transition towards a low-carbon economy and boosting the Prime Minister’s engagement on both the international and domestic agendas.
Matthew Spencer, director of Green Alliance said: ’The government has taken some good decisions in tough economic circumstances, but it is hobbled by a lack of cross-government support for the Coalition Programme. It will miss opportunities to get economic and political benefit from its policies without more public leadership from the Prime Minister and greater accountability across Whitehall.’
John Sauven, executive director of Greenpeace said: ‘This report shows that our Treasury and Department of Business are not backing British companies in the clean technology race. Right now our major global competitors are investing in low carbon energy. That investment is delivering jobs, raising valuable tax revenue and helping the fight against climate change, whilst here in the UK, those responsible for our economy seem blind to the opportunities that clean technology can offer.
‘If the government don’t wake up and grasp this generational chance, then UK PLC will lose out on jobs, on growth and much needed revenues.
Loretta Minghella, director of Christian Aid said: ‘Some ministers and officials have done great work towards a global solution to climate change - but the challenge is so tough and so pressing that we urgently need the Prime Minister himself to step up his engagement now.
In the run up to the UN climate talks in Durban, his personal leadership will be hugely important in securing the extension of the Kyoto Protocol - a vital bridge to the comprehensive, binding global climate deal that the world needs.’
David Nussbaum, chief executive of WWF-UK said: ‘Energy efficiency policy was one of the great environmental pledges of this government last May, but I am afraid that a lot of what was promised is threatening to be slowly dissipated through collective lack of nerve. Energy efficiency is good for householders, good for jobs, and good for the environment. There can be little reason for not going ahead.’
Mike Clarke, chief executive of RSPB said: ’There is a common thread running between the Government’s underwhelming performance on climate change, and its current, flawed approach to planning reform. We are seeing a clear conflict at the heart of the Coalition between green growth and economic growth at any cost. This report is our verdict on the Coalition’s climate change record so far, but being the ‘greenest government ever’ also means looking after our wildlife and green spaces. The RSPB and other conservation organisations will publish Nature Check later this year, which will examine the government’s record on delivering its natural environment commitments.’
i The low carbon section of the Coalition programme begins with recognition of the scale and urgency of the challenge and a commitment to an ambitious response: “The government believes that climate change is one of the gravest threats we face, and that urgent action at home and abroad is required. We need to use a wide range of levers to cut carbon emissions, decarbonise the economy and support the creation of new green jobs and technologies. We will implement a full programme of measures to fulfil our joint ambitions for a low carbon and eco-friendly economy.” HM Government, 2010, The Coalition: our programme for government, p.16
Edward Robinson, Green Alliance, 07825 767 775, email@example.com
Benjamin Ward, WWF, 07837 134 193, firstname.lastname@example.org
Rachel Baird, Christian Aid, 07545 501 749, RBaird@christian-aid.org
Nik Shelton, RSPB, 01767 693554/07739 921464, email@example.com
Niall Sookoo, Greenpeace, 07711 156 881, firstname.lastname@example.org
Christian Aid Notes to Editors:
1. Christian Aid works in some of the world's poorest communities in nearly 50 countries. We act where the need is greatest, regardless of religion, helping people build the lives they deserve.
2. Christian Aid has a vision, an end to global poverty, and we believe that vision can become a reality. Our report, Poverty Over, explains what we believe needs to be done – and can be done – to end poverty. Details at http://www.christianaid.org.uk/Images/poverty-over-report.pdf
3. Christian Aid is a member of the ACT Alliance, a global coalition of 100 churches and church-related organisations that work together inhumanitarian assistance and development. Further details at http://www.actalliance.org
4. Follow Christian Aid's newswire on Twitter: http://twitter.com/caid_newswire
5. For more information about the work of Christian Aid visit www.christianaid.org.uk